• Question: If I was to flood a nuclear power station what would happen? Apocalypse?

    Asked by Harry to Anna, James, Joe, Leonie, Olivia on 10 Mar 2015.
    • Photo: Leonie Oostwoud Wijdenes

      Leonie Oostwoud Wijdenes answered on 10 Mar 2015:


      Wow Harry, you asked some interesting but difficult questions! I’m afraid I don’t know anything about nuclear power. Sorry! I hope one of the other scientists can help out.

    • Photo: Joe Spencer

      Joe Spencer answered on 10 Mar 2015:


      Harry, I’m concerned, you want to have a water jet that rips through humans, now flooding a power plant….
      Okay here’s what’ll happen (as far as I can guess with my reasonable, but limited knowledge on nuclear power)
      The answer, probably not much. I mean sure you’ll break computers and cause a mess, but actually water is used in nuclear power plants to regulate and control the fission process, it acts as a cooling agent to stop ”meltdowns” which aren’t big horrible explosions, but merely things melting.
      But I think the most likely outcome is you’d be arrested before you even got to a nuclear power plant with your water.

      But again for the sake of argument let’s assume you did, and the worst case scenario did occur, containment failure. Radiation would spill out the power plant complex and around a few mile radius (wind speeds would effect this) people would have to abadon whole cities and leave their stuff to escape the fallout and you’d not be able to live there again. Infact this happened in chernobyll in 1986 or so.

      But it can’t really happen now. As I said, water if anything would actually make the situation better as it would cool the whole place down and prevent overheating, so maybe, just maybe if you flooded a reactor that was about to go critical you’d be thank’d and given a medal

    • Photo: James Pope

      James Pope answered on 11 Mar 2015:


      Hi Harry,

      In a nuclear reactor the reactor containing the radiation is sealed in, so that it has no contact with the outside world. That is really important, if it leaks out or explodes out, then we have very dangerous risks, were Chernobyl is the most famous example.

      The most likely example for your question, is what happened at the Fukishima Nuclear Power Plant in 2011 during a tsunami (a huge wave of water) after an earthquake off the coast of Japan.

      The tsunami breached the tsunami defences (partly because of the height of the wave, partly because the earthquake had lowered that coast of japan by 1 metre!!!)

      The tsunami flooded in, blew all the electrical power to the plant. The reactor was already shut down (a SCRAM event) as an automated response to the earthquake, so it was still radioactive material, but it wasn’t reacting. However, as the reactors (three I think) had been operating, there was still lots of heat in the reactor building. This should have been cooled by water flowing around the reactor, but with no electricity there was no water. A major emergency was declared and an urgent request for backup generators to provide electricty was made. However, due to the earthquake and tsunami the generators couldn’t get there in time.

      Thanks to the SCRAM shutdown, there was no chance for the reactors to go out of control like with Chernobyl, but with building heat, the reactors could meltdown. Pressure was increasing, so they were forced to vent slightly radioactive gas (which later exploded and blew up the outer building of the reactor, but not the reactor) and they discharged some of the cooling water into the sea (again slightly radioactive). Eventually, teh reactors got so hot they melted through their casing and into a specially designed safety feature, a huge thick lead and concrete container rthat caught the sludge, like the trays under plant pots do.

      Although some of the radioactivity reached all around the northern hemisphere, it was very limited in its effect outside of Japan. In Japan a number of young children had to have iodine tablets to prevent thyroid problems, which can be a side effect of iodine radiation. This was fairly common in Eastern Europe after Chernobyl, my fiancee is from Poland and her and all her friends had to have those tablets after that eruption.

      Hope that answers your question, if the reactors had been running, then I guess the loss of electrical power would also have caused the SCRAM shutdown, but I don’t know for sure.

      By the way, The Earthquake was 4 years ago today, the 11th March 2011!

    • Photo: Olivia Lynes

      Olivia Lynes answered on 12 Mar 2015:


      Well, even being the one who works in nuclear power the guys have got here first! Water is great for acting as a buffer between us and nuclear radiation.

      This comic is great for illustrating why the storage ponds (that I work on) are used, and why they pose no risk to us.

      https://what-if.xkcd.com/29/

Comments